Methods of Recovery
The high viscosity and density of heavy oil renders conventional production methods inefficient or even impossible. Because the viscosity of heavy oil is highly temperature dependent, the production of heavy oil is divided into hot and cold methods. When heated, heavy oil becomes less viscous and can be flowed from a well. Cold production, in which heating is not necessary, is only applicable when heavy oil viscosity at reservoir conditions is low enough for oil to flow on its own at economically viable rates.
Mining is one of several heavy oil recovery methods. In this open-pit method, the operator excavates thick, near-surface oil sand deposits and transports them to a processing facility, where oil and sand are separated by a hot water process. Most heavy oil mining occurs in Canada, where surface access, volumes produced and market prices favor the economic viability of this method. This method has a high recovery rate, but its associated carbon dioxide emission and environmental damage rates have stirred concern from both the public and the scientific community.
In reservoirs of the enormous Venezuela Orinoco heavy oil belt and some of the reservoirs offshore Brazil, heavy oil is sometimes produced by primary cold production. Using this method, oil is extracted from the reservoir; the oil is then allowed to flow into the wells under natural reservoir conditions. Primary cold production recovery factors in the Venezuelan oil sands are around 8% to 12% of total oil in place. In primary cold production, operators optimize production by drilling horizontal and multilateral wells to reach as much of the reservoir as possible. Operators may also decrease crude viscosity by adding diluents or deploying artificial lift technology, primarily electrical submersible and progressing cavity pumps to force the hydrocarbons to the surface. Primary cold production comes at relatively low cost, but recovery factors are also low.
Cold heavy oil production with sand (CHOPS) is a method applied to primary production; Canada is the only country that uses CHOPS widely. Used in unconsolidated sandstone reservoirs containing viscous heavy oil, CHOPS is inexpensive to implement but recovers only 5% to 10% of the reserves in place. When CHOPS is used, production has an initial sand influx of 10% to 40% of the volume of produced liquids and solids. The sand cut decreases with time to a constant 0.5% to 10%, depending on oil viscosity. Sand movement, aided by gas exsolution from the depressurized oil, increases fluid mobility and forms channels or wormholes, in the formation which increases the size of the high permeability zone around the well.
Gas production from CHOPS is substantial because of trapped gas in the viscous heavy oil; the gas/oil ratio generally stays constant over several years. Oil production reaches its maximum rate within months of first production and then declines as reservoir depletion effects become dominant. The CHOPS method typically requires an artificial lift system to bring the oil and sand to the surface, where the two are separated by gravity. The sand contaminated with hydrocarbons must be disposed of, which is considered a drawback of the method; much of the contaminated sand is stored in underground salt caverns.
Cyclic steam stimulation (CSS) and steam flooding are the most common thermal heavy oil recovery processes. Cyclic steam stimulation is a single-well method that is applied in stages. This steam soak method is initiated by injecting steam into a well. During the steam soaking, the oil is heated to reduce its viscosity and enable production. The oil and water are brought to the surface and separated, and the process is repeated. Steam flooding is a multiwell method, in which steam is injected continuously into one or more wells and oil is driven to production wells. For steam flooding, wells are usually placed in regular patterns. The CSS and steam flooding methods are used worldwide and yield high initial production rates and recovery factors that can reach around 30%.
In recent years, operators in Canada have tested the vapor extraction (VAPEX) method. The method is efficient because it can significantly decrease oil viscosity through solvent dissolution. Solvent vapor, which is injected into the reservoir, expands and dilutes the heavy oil by contact. The VAPEX method employs a pair of vertically stacked, parallel horizontal injection-production wells, and the process uses a combination of vaporized solvent— propane or butane or a mixture— and a commercially available noncondensable gas such as methane. Engineers inject the gaseous solvent mixture into the upper well, enabling the creation of a vapor chamber around the wellbore from which diluted heavy oil drains by gravity to the lower well. Vapor extraction represents an energy efficient alternative for heavy oil recovery in fields and reservoirs for which thermal methods may be unsuited or not economic.
Thermal recovery methods heat the reservoir and provide generally higher recovery factors than do cold methods but at a higher cost. The steam-assisted gravity drainage (SAGD) method is used mainly in reservoirs containing extraheavy oil and bitumen. As in the VAPEX method, the SAGD process uses pairs of parallel horizontal wellbores drilled in the same vertical plane. Steam is injected into the upper wellbore and forced out into the surrounding formation to form a steam-affected volume called a steam chamber. The steam expands upward and laterally, heating the oil in situ to lower its viscosity, especially at the steam-oil front. The oil can be heated to above 200°C [400°F], reducing the viscosity to around 0.01 Pa.s, which enables fluid mobilization. Gravity causes the mobilized oil and condensed steam mixture to flow down to the lower wellbore, from which it is pumped to the surface. Initial communication between the upper and lower well is established by steam circulation in both wells. The SAGD method is used in many fields in Canada because much of Western Canada's heavy oil is too deep to mine; the estimated recovery factor for this method is 50% to 70%. It is, however, a capital-intensive production method; steam generation is costly and makes up the majority of the operating expenses. In some cases, formation layering can include horizontal barriers that impede steam from contacting the oil within the steam chamber, thereby reducing recovery.
Fireflooding, or in situ combustion, is the movement of a burning front inside the reservoir; this method, which has been used for more than 90 years, mobilizes high viscosity oils from heat provided by combustion. Toe-to-heel air injection (THAI) is an in situ gravity-controlled combustion process that uses air injection to fuel combustion to crack, upgrade and mobilize heavy oil.
Heavy oil reservoirs constitute a large percentage of the world's oil reserves, and the recovery of these reserves may be crucial in satisfying the steadily increasing global appetite for energy. Looking ahead, the focus lies on optimizing available recovery techniques such as SAGD and THAI while also broadening the search for alternative methods. The reserves are there; now the industry must learn to exploit them economically and safely.
Oilfield Review 2016.
Copyright © 2016 Schlumberger.
For help in preparation of this article, thanks to David Hin-Sum Law, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada